Item Talk:Westfold Jeweller's Journal Recipe

The Recipe/Crafting template has 2 problems

1. There is no "Trophy" necessary for a Critical Success -- not "No Critical Trophy Available" -- non-descriptive/not-meaningful wording.
2. The Critical Chance value is 25%, not 5%

The base Critical Chance of 25% is common on ALL Westfold Recipes for Scholar. Haven't verified the other crafts yet. Some recipes have NO Critical Chance. (And therefore no critical items to be used) —The preceding unsigned comment was added by Magill (Contribs • User Talk).

Are you sure the 25% isn't from your crafting tools? I don't have a Westfold scholar, but my Westfold tailor and jeweller both have the standard 5% crit chance, plus whatever bonus the tools provide.

Perhaps that "No Critical Trophy Available" text was in the game at some point? I don't remember it, nor am I sure why it's there. But it means just what it says: there's no trophy you can use that will further increase the critical chance. Many recipes do allow critical trophies, so I guess it could be good to distinguish those that don't. -- Elinnea (talk) 01:12, 3 April 2012 (EDT)

Hmmm... 25% could be the 5% + the 20% ... sure enough, if I un-equip my tools ! That's new ... the tools didn't use to show in that figure -- let alone change in real-time! Wm Magill - Valamar - OTG/OTC (talk) 01:46, 3 April 2012 (EDT)