Talk:The Horsefields

Jump to navigation Jump to search

Why deleting it? We also redirect from Shire and similar "The" titles. Why not the other way round, too? --EoD (talk) 21:24, 16 October 2011 (EDT)

If this redirect is really used it should stay, but it is not.
One reason to why not have redirects would be to indicate to an editor that "The Something" is not the correct name but the "Something" is. But with The or not The I agree that The is The Question ;)
A contra-argument is that now Turbine seems to have "updated" several names from without the to with the, making some of our recent name-changes obsolete. Then ... reading LotR books again I find names that JRRTolkien spelled with The, so ...
I am not really biased on this but consider an unused redirect as target for deletion. It is cheap to later put it back if there is a good reason for that. -- Zimoon (talk) 02:50, 17 October 2011 (EDT)