User talk:Sagarmatha

From Lotro-Wiki.com
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Thanks for the excellent work on those deed pages. You're a Ninja now. Keep it up! -- Neum (talk) 07:51, 1 April 2018 (UTC)

Thanks for your continued contributions, you have been promoted to editor. --Lotroadmin (talk) 07:15, 21 January 2019 (UTC)
Looks like you've crossed over to the world of Admin. Great job on your edits and hard work. Rogue (talk) 21:10, 23 February 2020 (UTC)

Gundabad Craft Recipe Selection Box

I guess we were creating same time. I had checked before I started on it and no one had set them up yet :D. Main reason I had the lowercase selection box was based off past experience with some that had shown in game as capitalized but were listed lower case on here, not first occurrence I've seen of it so just went with that. Doesn't help of course that Lotro alternates itself it seems some essence boxes have capitals and yet festival garments dont lol. Also I was working just from screenshots from Laurelsden at the time. I dont know which version we should keep I admittedly like the tables I added on mine :D Yours does have information that was missing on the one Id just finished though so maybe a merge of the two on to the Selection Box one. Hope that all makes sense late night editing you know how it goes lol. Eldalleth (talk) 10:41, 19 August 2022 (UTC)

  • I picked up the box in-game late last night and was finally able to see the items within it. When I saw the lowercase "selection box" link, I wondered about the capitalization. When I did a search of "selection box" I discovered the capitalization discrepancy as you mentioned so I then went to Lotro Companion and it was using "Selection Box". I hadn't noticed that festival garments were using "selection box". I believe that generally SSG is using first letter cap convention for item names except when they add a dash, however SSG's consistency department seems to be minimally staffed. I find it a bit strange to see "selection box" in an item name when used to the first letter cap convention. Adding the profession column is a good idea; adding that to my version briefly crossed my mind but then I thought when the actual recipe pages are added, people will know which recipe requires what profession. However, it makes sense to have it listed on the selection box page. At this point, I believe "Selection Box" is the correct capitalization but am open to further discussion on it, perhaps bring it up in Discord for others to comment before a final decision? Or if you agree this is correct, I can merge in the recipe names from my version of the page as these were taken directly from opening the box in-game or from Lotro Companion. Sagarmatha (talk) 17:47, 19 August 2022 (UTC)